The Online Library of Liberty

Search the library

Press Enter to see all results. Esc closes.

Economics

Malthus: For and Against

13 items in this collection

About this collection

In this collection

Titles

7 titles, earliest first.

In this collection

People

Authors, editors and translators of these titles, most titles first.

Quotes

Passages on this subject, chosen by OLL editors.

  • Liberty

    As you may recall, Dicey dates the change in public opinion in Britain away from individualism and toward collectivism at about 1870-90. Dicey answers his question by essentially reversing it, saying that in its original form, it may be a foolish question. Perhaps the relevant question is not why people turned away from individualism toward collectivism, but how they were induced to accept the queer notion of individualism in the first place. The argument for a free society, he goes on to say, is a very subtle and sophisticated argument. At every point, it depends on the indirect rather than the direct effect of the policy followed. If one is concerned to remedy clear evils in a society, as everyone is, the natural reaction is to say, “let’s do something about it,” and the “us” in this statement will in a large number of cases be translated into the “government,” so the natural reaction is to pass a law. The argument that maybe the attempt to correct this particular evil by extending the hand of the government will have indirect effects whose aggregate consequences may be far worse than any direct benefits that flow from the action taken is, after all, a rather sophisticated argument. And yet, this is the kind of argument that underlies a belief in a free or laisser-faire society. (FROM: Is a Free Society Stable?) - Milton Friedman