
Writings on Standing Armies
- David Womersley(editor)
The questions of where to locate, in whose hands to place, and how to exercise the state’s powers of deadly military force inform a perennial topic in political theory and coalesce into a recurrent problem in political practice. Liberty Fund presents Writings on Standing Armies, a newly collected, authoritative edition of the most important pamphlets on the “standing armies” controversy of 1697–98. In addition, these writings express a subtext that is of equal and enduring importance: the transforming effects exerted by the prolonged possession of power on individuals and administrations.
About This Edition
Citation
Whether arms should be entrusted to a standing army or reserved to a citizen militia is a central theme in a political tradition that descends from Machiavelli. Part of the popular grievance against James II in the years leading up to the Glorious Revolution had been suspicion of his maintenance of troops in time of peace, because it was feared this might be used as an instrument of absolutism. Therefore, when the Bill of Rights was drawn up in 1689, one of the articles explicitly addressed this concern, specifying “the raising and keeping a Standing Army, within this Kingdom, in time of Peace, without Consent of Parliament” as one of James II’s transgressions against his people, and consequently declared that “the raising or keeping a Standing Army within this Kingdom in time of Peace, unless it be with Consent of Parliament, is against Law.” However, in the 1690s, William III had steadily increased the number of his troops until, by 1696, it exceeded the number maintained by James II. The crisis split the Whigs into those determined to stand by the principle of opposition to standing armies versus those content to modify principles for the practical exigencies of government. David Womersley’s introduction situates these texts in the European debate about standing armies and places them in the narrower context of the specifically English altercations on the subject during the reigns of William III, George I, and George II.
Womersley, David. Writings on Standing Armies. Liberty Fund, 2020. Online Library of Liberty, https://oll.libertyfund.org/titles/writings-on-standing-armies.
Womersley, D. (2020). Writings on Standing Armies. Liberty Fund. https://oll.libertyfund.org/titles/writings-on-standing-armies
@book{womersley2020armies,
editor = {David Womersley},
title = {Writings on Standing Armies},
publisher = {Liberty Fund},
address = {Indianapolis},
year = {2020},
url = {https://oll.libertyfund.org/titles/writings-on-standing-armies},
note = {Online Library of Liberty}
}TY - BOOK A2 - Womersley, David TI - Writings on Standing Armies PY - 2020 CY - Indianapolis PB - Liberty Fund UR - https://oll.libertyfund.org/titles/writings-on-standing-armies DB - Online Library of Liberty ER -
Copyright
The copyright to this edition, in both print and electronic forms, is held by Liberty Fund, Inc.
About the author
David Womersley b. 1957
David Womersley is the Thomas Warton Professor of English Literature at the
University of Oxford. His monographs include Divinity and State (OUP), Gibbon and the “Watchmen of the Holy City” (OUP), T*he Transformation of the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire* (CUP), and Thinking Through Shakespeare (Princeton UP).
Related People
John Locke
Author
A 17th-century philosopher who argued that governments exist by the consent of the governed to protect natural rights like life, liberty, and property.
Benjamin Constant
Author
A 19th-century liberal thinker who championed individual freedom and warned against both ancient models of collective sovereignty and modern centralized power.
Richard Henry Lee
Author
An American statesman and Anti-Federalist who advocated for strong protections of individual rights and warned that the new U.S. Constitution would threaten liberty without a Bill of Rights.
Critical Responses
Works that answer or challenge this text.
- Book
On War
Carl von ClausewitzView title >Clausewitz's book is not a direct critique but offers a very different view: that standing armies are an inevitable part of political life because war is a continuation of politics by other means.
BookA Well-Regulated Militia: The Founding Fathers and the Origins of Gun Control in America
Saul CornellVisit site ↗Cornell shows that while Anti-Federalists opposed standing armies, their solutions (local militias) were complicated, messy, and not always practical—hinting that standing armies became necessary despite the ideological preference for militias.
BookThe Federalist Papers
Alexander HamiltonFederalist No. 24, 25, and 26
View title >Hamilton defends the need for a standing army in peacetime, arguing that dangers abroad and internal unrest require national military preparedness.
BookThe American Way of War
Russell F. WeigleyVisit site ↗Weigley argues that while fears of standing armies were important, they were often based more on historical memory and political ideology than on practical needs for national security.
Connected Readings
What to read next.
BookCato’s Letters, 4 vols. in 2 (LF ed.)
Thomas GordonView title >Vigorous defenses of liberty against tyranny, corruption, and standing armies, highly influential on American revolutionaries.
BookDiscourses Concerning Government
Algernon SidneyView title >A foundational text arguing for limited government, popular sovereignty, and the citizen’s right to resist standing armies and centralized power.
BookThe Commonwealth of Oceana
James HarringtonVisit site ↗A classic work of republican thought that stresses the balance between military and civil institutions.
BookComplete Works, vol. 1 The Spirit of Laws
Charles Louis de Secondat, Baron de MontesquieuView title >Explores the dangers of despotism and the importance of separating military and civil authority.
BookThe Creation of the American Republic
Gordon S. WoodVisit site ↗Read this for a historian’s view of how fears of standing armies shaped U.S. constitutional design.
BookThe Man versus the State, with Six Essays on Government, Society and Freedom (LF ed.)
Herbert SpencerView title >Spencer's book is useful for thinking about centralized coercive forces in the 19th century.




