“The College breaks up in the beginning of June and does not sit down again till the beginning of October. During this interval I propose that he should learn french and Dancing and fencing and that besides he should read with me the best greek, latin and french Authors on Moral Philosophy for two or three hours every morning, so that he will not be idle in the vacation.”
Education
Adam Smith on who colleges and universities ACTUALLY benefit
The discipline of colleges and universities is in general contrived, not for the benefit of the students, but for the interest, or more properly speaking, for the ease of the masters. Its object is, in all cases, to maintain the authority of the master, and whether he neglects or performs his duty, to oblige the students in all cases to behave to him as if he performed it with the greatest diligence and ability. It seems to presume perfect wisdom and virtue in the one order, and the greatest weakness and folly in the other. Where the masters, however, really perform their duty, there are no examples, I believe, that the greater part of the students ever neglect theirs. No discipline is ever requisite to force attendance upon lectures which are really worth the attending, as is well known wherever any such lectures are given.
Context
The Scottish moral philosopher Adam Smith (1723–1790) was the author of two books, The Theory of Moral Sentiments (1759) and An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations (1776).
In Book V, Chapter 1, Part 3, Article 2 of Wealth of Nations, Smith discusses education. Smith believes that, in general, education should be capable of paying most of its expenses through fees paid by students to teachers. However, since public endowments were made to many schools, Smith discusses whether or not they improve the education of Britain's youth.
Further thoughts
Smith believes that in teaching, as in all professions, people work hardest and best when they are rewarded for working hard and well. He also believes that, as with in professions, competition between teachers for customers (students or their parents) will encourage teachers to improve their teaching.
Public endowments reduce the necessity of relying upon fees paid by students to teachers. This reduces teachers’ motivation to work hard to earn their pay or to teach better to avoid losing students to their competitors. Teachers who receive all of their income in the form of a salary will feel the cost of having to work when they teach but will not receive the benefit of increased income from more and better teaching.
Things get even worse when universities force their students to study under certain teachers or forbid them from studying outside of the university. (Smith grants that it’s reasonable to force young boys to attend class.) Forcing students to attend the lectures of particular professors reduces further the motivation to provide value for students by further reducing the competition that professors face for students’ time.
When professors earn their incomes from a salary paid by the public and are guaranteed students by their schools, professors’ positions in the university are more secure but the education offered to students suffers.
Public endowments therefore, by divorcing professors and institutions from the monetary incentives to perform well for students, allow the people who teach in and manage educational institutions to support their own comfort rather than improve the services they provide.
This doesn’t mean that Smith believes that when the public pays teachers’ salaries there are never good teachers. Reputation still matters and good teachers won’t enjoy teaching poorly. But the poor financial incentives may mean that some teachers who could offer excellent education with the right motivation might instead pursue their own comfort and ease without consideration for their students.
Found in
Read the passage in context, or cite the edition.
More on Education
- Education
- Education
“The reading of these speeches added much to my limited stock of language, and enabled me to give tongue to many interesting thoughts which had often flashed through my mind and died away for want of words in which to give them utterance. The mighty power and heart-searching directness of truth penetrating the heart of a slave-holder, compelling him to yield up his earthly interests to the claims of eternal justice, were finely illustrated in the dialogue; and from the speeches of Sheridan I got a bold and powerful denunciation of oppression and a most brilliant vindication of the rights of man. Here was indeed a noble acquisition. If I had ever wavered under the consideration that the Almighty, in some way, had ordained slavery, and willed my enslavement for His own glory, I wavered no longer. I had now penetrated to the secret of all slavery and all oppression, and had ascertained their true foundation to be in the pride, the power, and the avarice of man. With a book in my hand so redolent of the principles of liberty, with a perception of my own human nature, and the facts of my past and present experience, I was equal to a contest with the religious advocates of slavery, whether white or black,—for blindness in this matter was not confined to the white people.”
Frederick Douglass: The ex-slave Frederick Douglass reveals that reading speeches by English politicians produced in him a deep love of liberty and hatred of oppression (1882)
The Life and Times of Frederick Douglass: From 1817-1882
- Education
“... despite their differences the Revolutionary generation did achieve independence, they did write a number of strikingly similar state constitutions, and they did draft and put into operation the federal Constitution. What underlay and made possible these monumental accomplishments, however, was not a universally accepted set of philosophical principles. Rather, I suggest, most Americans shared a common matrix of ideas and assumptions about government and society, about liberty and property, about politics and law. These ideas and assumptions, together with the belief (however inaccurate) that they shared a common historical heritage, made their achievements possible. They derived those ideas and assumptions, as well as their perception of their heritage, from a variety of sources, but the principal wellspring was the printed word. [Reading Habits of Early Americans]”
Forrest McDonald: Forrest McDonald discusses the reading habits of colonial Americans and concludes that their thinking about politics and their shared values was based upon their wide reading, especially of history (1978)
Literature of Liberty, January/March 1978, vol. 1, No. 1


