In setting out upon a journey through hell while simultaneously desiring to write an epic poem about the journey, Dante is following the precedents of both the poet Virgil and his poetic subject Aeneas—incarnating two roles (the writer/chronicler as well as the the adventurer/hero) within the mind and body of a single soul.
Dante also reflects upon how
Saint Paul (as recounted in the New Testament) also journeyed through heaven and hell while still living. ‘Yes,’ Dante thinks out loud, ‘these two people, Aeneas and Paul, may have travelled to the supernal realms before I have, but they were great figures—a legendary hero and revered saint. Who am I that I should be worthy of making this same journey? Whom am I that I should be able to follow in their footsteps?’
Dante, as we saw in Canto I, had agreed to let Virgil be his guide through the underworld (and had resolved to make the classics his guide through life). All of a sudden, though—before he is about to set forth with Virgil upon this epic journey through hell, purgatory, and beyond—he stops. Why?
Almost all of us, at some point in our lives, have been—or will be—in situations in which we are called on to lead. Even though we may be eminently qualified for the task, an overwhelming sense of inadequacy suddenly begins to grip us, making us feel unqualified for the role. We may have been preparing our entire lives for this very thing, and yet, in the moment when we are finally about to begin to put all of our training into practice—to finally teach that first class, write that first review, argue that first court case, or make that first conference presentation—our confidence in ourselves abruptly falters, and we feel an overpowering urge to withdraw and retreat back into the safe, secure, stake-free confines of our pre-achieving selves. We today call this sensation the “impostor syndrome,” and we may be surprised to learn that Dante—perhaps the greatest poet of the past thousand years—felt it just as keenly as anyone.
Today we know Dante as a world-renowned poet with a towering reputation, writer of The Divine Comedy, the greatest post-classical-era epic poem in Western literature. How could Dante—Dante!, for heaven’s sakes!—suffer a bout of impostor syndrome? And yet, this is precisely what occurs. Before beginning his epic journey with Virgil, Dante pauses to consider the two great figures of antiquity who had undertaken a similar journey—the Trojan warrior Aeneas and the Christian saint Paul—and feels woefully inadequate in comparison to them. Why should he, Dante Alighieri, a middling, middle-aged Tuscan poet and political pariah who’d had a few literary successes at that point in his life but still hadn’t achieved anything truly monumental—be worthy of being able to embark on an adventure that only a handful of some of the truly greatest figures in world history were able to undertake?
Moreover, Dante had wanted to assume the double burden of not only undertaking this adventure, but writing about it as well—to assume the role of both Aeneas and Virgil. When thinking about the task before him, it is no wonder that he began to have some doubts. How many of us would choose to try to not only write a Broadway play but to play the lead role in it as well?
As we proceed through Canto II we’ll see how Dante overcomes his impostor syndrome, but for now, we should be comforted by the knowledge that Dante also experiences it himself. It is completely normal to feel a sudden sensation of inadequacy sweep over us right before we’re about to begin something we’ve been training and preparing our entire lives for; whenever we experience these feelings, all we need to remember is that Dante Alighieri felt them, too. Even
Moses did; before he became the legendary Moses of the Bible, he was a humble, stuttering shepherd who, when asked by God to lead the Jewish people out of Egypt, responds, "Why me? I’m really not very good with words. Send someone else instead."
In one of the greatest matches ever played in the history of professional tennis—the 2019 Wimbledon gentleman’s singles final, the epic match between Roger Federer and Novak Djokovic (and the first-ever Wimbledon final to be decided in a 5th set tiebreak at 12-all)—the Serbian great Djokovic found himself down 7-8 in the final set, staring down two match points, at 15-40. The legendary Swiss Federer had the match on his racquet—two chances to close out the championship on his own serve. The London crowd at the All England Lawn & Tennis Croquet Club was overwhelmingly pro-Federer; fans were chanting “Ro-ger!” “Ro-ger!”, and holding up one finger, signaling that their man was only one point away from his twenty-first Grand Slam championship. The momentum, the fans, the stadium, and seemingly the cosmos itself, were all conspiring against Djokovic. How did he overcome not only Federer but all of these other forces? What was going through his head in those moments, during those pivotal match points?
Djokovic explained that in his moments of greatest self-doubt he always strives to reinforce his sense of self-belief: “You have to keep reminding yourself that you are there for a reason, and that you are better than the other guy. And as hard as the moment, you know, is, that you are in, the more you have to remind yourself—the more you have to talk to yourself.”
Like Djokovic, and like Dante, we can all find our own ways of believing that we belong on the court with legends like Federer and that we do belong on the same page as great heroes and saints like Aeneas and Paul. In those moments of hesitancy and creeping self-doubt, we should remember that there is a reason that we are even in this position in the first place—that we wouldn’t be here about to make that big presentation or lead that important meeting were it not for the fact that we have indeed earned it; we are qualified to be here. Like Dante yesterday, and like Djokovic today, in our moments of greatest self-doubt, we should remind ourselves—as hard as it may be to believe in that moment—that we are here for a reason, and that we really do belong on this stage after all.